sex with my best friend... he says i love you, not cool
Posted February 1st, 2009 by macintoshfan
I'm having sex with my best friend. I don't want to date him, I thought we both made that clear to each other. He tells me that he loves me, I say it back... but only to appease him. I feel horrible about the whole situation. I know that if I tell him he needs to just give up, lets just be friends--he will simply stop being my friend and force me out of his life completely, which I don't even see as an option. He is my best friend, I don't know what to do other than count down the days until college graduation (3 months away) and hope that when we go our separate ways after graduation we can still be friends and him being head-over-heals in love with me will fade...
Filed under:


Comments
cybil said:
fade it will (though i still remember the last one from collee... 25 years ago!)
Shy said:
fuck u nigger
Shy said:
dats rite white man
Shy said:
if he is your best friend then whats the problem?
Shy said:
ur a jewbag, thats the problem.
Shy said:
fucking moron
Shy said:
Hurray for friends with benefits and how it can really mess with someones psyche! Congratulations, it sounds like you opened up "Pandora's Box". Don't say "I love you" back if you don't mean it. I'm a firm believer that one does not say something if it is not meant.
Shy said:
you don't like him then why did you have sex
Darkangel said:
If you don't love him, then why say it back? You should have told him outright you just like him as a friend rather than lead the poor guy on.
Shy said:
I'm going through the same thing, and i really can't wait to grad and go to uni, you are not alone. Ignore 'shy' and 'darkangel' when someone you care about says that they love you and you feel in a position where you have to say it back its really, really hard not too.
My bf asked me out, and i said yes, and i shouldn't have done, the only reason we are going to have sex (And it will happen) is because i want to make him happy, but i don't love him. I put of having sex for a few months now. I need to break up with him but i'm getting deeper and deeper into this relationship. Even though i know i don't love him. I can't put of having sex with him any longer and I can't bring myself to break up with him. You are right, If we split it's gonna be a bad split and there is no way we would be able to be friends. But i feel as if i can't split with him because of how he will react., because of his personality type. But i know the longer we stay together the more chance i will spend the rest of my life with him, and i don't want to do that.
And another part of me is thinking, you have found a really great bloke who is really in love with you and cares for you and listens, and you share similar interests and if i was older i would marry and have kids with, because he is secure and safe and love matters less when you are older than comfort and security.
So will love fade? Depends on his personality. But the longer you leave it the more you are just going to develop the bond between you in the wrong way. Perhaps if you are lucky he will fall in love with someone else, but there is no guarantee.
I'm thinking of maybe pretending I'm gay (The more i think about it the more attractive the possibility seems)
Respect and Best of Luck
Shy said:
my female friend asked me to have sex with her even tho i want too but i she was my friend so i said no and its hard for me coz i luv her so in ur case i say just keep it ur self
if u want to still be friends
Shy said:
You have to be a little more responsible with other people's feelings in the future. Why don't you just enjoy the sex then move on after college? No need to feel guilty, have a good time!
Shy said:
UHMM. "Be responsible with their feelings, so you should just use them and then disappear forever to college?" WOW. That's pretty much the most contradictory thing I've ever heard.
The guy said he loved her - and then she's having regrets for not wanting to go along with it.
Being responsible for people's feelings would mean setting the story straight. If it were me, I think I would nicely turn them down and tell them that they will always be special to me, but as friends.
This is one of those places where regardless of how close you two are, talking about it really doesn't help - especially if it's the guy who's head over heels in love. Emotionally coping with that kind of a turn-down is HIS responsibility, and unfortunately it's something that the person refusing him can't help him with - for HIS sake. (don't tell him that... he'll figure out eventually that he needs to be out for himself).
If you're still friends after that it's gonna be tough, but you gotta draw a line. He'll handle his feelings better if you do.
Shy said:
I've got a similar situation to yours, except I'm the guy who's in love in the "relationship", so hopefully I can shed some advice here...
She's my best friend... she's seen me at my best and worst, really cares for me and has been a wonderful support right through my adult life. I'm honoured to know that before she completely turned me down, she had to think really hard about it. It was very hard for her, but I'm glad that she helped me understand what her feelings are; I'm sure once I've moved on completely, I'll appreciate it even more.
She and I have each felt head-over-heels love once in our lives, but never with each other. I dated someone that I met through her (before I realized that I had these feelings for my best friend), and she's having those feelings now, but it isn't "really" reciprocated. There's a certain strangeness to his character that repulses her, and based on what she's told me, it sounds like he's a slight womanizer. Either way, nothing's happening there, and that's why I'm still around. :p
We haven't had sex yet, but she's told me that she's "tired of being stuck". We spoke about it with interest, but fell to the back-burner, probably because I didn't want to be forward and proposition her when I clearly had to move on. Then, one night she starts kissing me out of the blue when we were at a mutual female friend's place. It almost happened that night, but there was another guest, and so we decided it would be best to save the fun for another time.
I'll admit, I really do love her, but I've refocused my energy such that it's in an unconditionally friendly way. I had come on really suddenly, and I think that may have hurt my chances. Also, I'm a pretty depressed person when my life isn't in a good balance, which was one of her reasons for actually dating me for a bit. If this is the case with your friend, he needs to think about how hard it would be for you to do what you're doing for him. Of course, if you talk to him, separate what you're doing for him from what you're doing for yourself in the relationship. I mean, he's clearly a close friend of yours, and you enjoy your time with him. It's important to outline why you like him in the way that you truthfully do.
In my case, my friend pinned me as a great model boyfriend with whom it "could be nice" to get together with. She also enjoys my company, talks to me about whatever is bothering her, etc. Through our experience of me having professed love to her, we've become even closer, because after having had this ultimate test, I can really talk to her about anything without shame, including sex and other topics that aren't usually open to common, even close discussion.
Another important note: it's not easy to get over someone whom you've been close to, so do expect fallout. If you care for him, I would make effort to spend plenty of time with him even after you have to break up. The reason for that is, he will need time to adjust to the situation and explore himself. It is so much easier when the best person that you can talk to is the person with whom you're breaking up with. Of course, you'll need to monitor the space between you both, as you're the one who will have to lead him to the outcome that you desire. If you're afraid that he'll resent you for the time you spent dating, consider why he feels so close to you. I know that in my case with my "girl friend", I could never put anything before our friendship, and so I can only see what she did as acting in good faith, because she loves me so unconditionally that she would consider doing something painful for her to benefit me, as much as really, I would never want her to.
But seriously, give him the reality check and allow him to see what it is that you're actually doing for him. Let him decide how he wants to deal with the situation, but guide him firmly when need be so that he doesn't fall back in.
The best of luck to you, my relationship with my best friend only improved after this.
John
Shy said:
suck my peniss
Shy said:
what the f*ck is wrong with you people to have sex with a friend that loves you!! do you even know what it does to the other person. well i can tell you because thats me...im in love with my best friend and ive been sleeping with him and its doing nothing but killing me inside...now im in so deep i cant cut him off because i cant live without him in my life and now ive fell in to such a deep depression over it all, all i do is cry and stay in bed...i dont talk to my friends anymore, i cant eat because nothing tasste right, and im misrable...thats what this shit does when u dont make yourself clear that ur just friends and thats all its going to be...if you want ass go bang some random person but dont hurt the people who love u its not fair to them like it isnt fair to me
Shy said:
Thanks so much, I think I just found the answers to my questions in your response. I was in the middle of making out with my best friend when it started to feel not right. I stopped and asked if he loved me. He paused. I broke the silence by saying that I loved him, that I didn't think friends should have sex, and that it would be unfair for me if we proceeded to do it. He said I was so important and incredible to him, but he wasn't in love with me. And then we put our clothes back on.
This happened quite recently. For several days afterward I even tried to convince myself that he actually loved me but was held back by things such as our distance and his unreadiness for a new relationship. But I guess at this point it doesn't matter, I should remain the friendship as it was and move on emotionally. I could see myself falling into the deep depression that you experienced, being fully aware of the prospect of losing him and having so little power over this "relationship". I hope things are better for you now.
But yes, people should never have sex with friends, whether it's you or the other person that is in love.
Shy said:
wat the fuck u say u love him but u dont mean it wat the hell is wrong with u bithccccccccccc get a fuckin live
Shy said:
I have to say I agree with the person who made the recent comment. I've been hurt many times by guys who have said this time and again to me and have never meant it. Only bitches and male whores do this.
Shy said:
Your a Moron and a skank. One day he'll meet someone real. So leave him alone, tell its over so he can rightfully have nothing to do with you and find a decent woman. You want your best friend for emotional contact and some a-hole for sex..Your a nasty skank
gracebadham said:
Hi there, I dont know if I am writing in a proper board but I have got a problem with activation, link i receive in email is not working... http://www.answerjam.com/?8b65455735f51b67801d2ebe929,
Shy said:
True love never fades. If he is really in love with you, he will be forever even if he tells you otherwise later on.
Post new comment